1. Fitzgerald uses many symbols to contribute to his main theme of the failure of the American dream, so which symbol is most effective to help support his theme?
The eyes of Dr. T.J. Eckelburg are mentioned every time characters pass through the Valley of Ashes and his appearance is particularly noticeable during the death of Myrtle Wilson. His representation of God serves not only that purpose, but also the eyes of Fitzgerald himself commenting on the moral decline of America, specifically its values. Additionally, God serves as the moral compass for the society, so it is natural that God would be disgusted with the behavior of the society similar to the judging eyes of T.J. Eckelburg during the death of Myrtle Wilson when they are staring down at Daisy who just killed a woman. Moreover, Fitzgerald's overarching theme of the failure of the American dream is also fairly apparent because through this symbol God's disdain is evident, which in turn shows Fitzgerald's disgust with the society of the 1920's.
2. Knowing Fitzgerald's background with failure and rejection, how are his own issues similar to Gatsby's, who possibly could represent Fitzgerald himself?
After finishing the novel and reading about Fitzgerald's background in class, I became aware of the fact that many of the same issues are present in both situations: public rejection by lovers, extramarital affairs, and the crushing of dreams. Similar to the rejection of Fitzgerald by his lover after college because of social class, Daisy publicly dismisses Gatsby during his profession of his love in the Plaza Hotel, " 'I never loved [Gatsby],'she said, with perceptible reluctance"(132). Even though there is reluctance in her voice, she still renounces Gatsby for money like she did five years previously. Throughout the novel there are multiple affairs and indiscretions, which is parallel to his own lifestyle, constantly cheating on his wife, Zelda. Furthermore, Fitzgerald's dreams were crushed by happenstance, comparable to the crushing of Gatsby's dream to marry Daisy. The best writer is the writer that writes about what he knows, which is definitely visible is Fitzgerald's novels because he fictionalizes his own life through them.
3. What purpose does Gatsby's father serve at the end of the novel?
The primary theme is the novel is the emptiness of upper-class life and Gatsby's father gives the reader a "reality check" with the rest of America. His appearance is quite sudden and shocked me, but at the same time his appearance reminds me of Gatsby's humble background showing how Gatsby broke the "glass ceiling" and joined the upper-class. I appreciated his behavior in comparison to the other shallow attendees of Gatsby's funeral because he was the sole person actually there that cared about the deceased.
4. Why is Myrtle Wilson's death so symbolic?
After Myrtle Wilson's death, the rest of the novel primarily focuses on the repercussions of Myrtle's death, which, I think, translates to some importance and does not just serve as a way for Gatsby to be killed. Although her death is sudden and unexpected, I think it can be said that her death was forcasted throughout the novel by the eyes of Dr. T.J. Eckelburg. It may seem odd, but this symbol represents the eyes of God and their importance are reiterated throughout. The eyes are constantly watching the moral violations of characters every time they pass through the Valley of Ashes, so it was only a matter of time before God punished the characters for their defiance. Myrtle's death represents the death of the moral values of America, which is Fitzgerald's main purpose.